| | | Scores + Tasting | 155 articles | -
A WINE STORY | WEDNESDAY, APRIL 25, 2012 Exploring the Wines of Chateau Picque Caillou During this week, journalists are divided into small groups to taste the wines of various regions each day. am in the "blind" tasting group with several other top name journalists and together we will taste the whites and the reds of the Grand Cru Classe De Graves "blind.". Opening hours: Wine tasting reservations and visits. -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, APRIL 18, 2012 La Presse: SAQ paid Suckling $24,000 for reviews Suckling, the former Wine Spectator critic and European bureau chief, went to Montreal in early 2011 to taste wines and produce tasting notes that would appear both on his website and on that of the SAQ , he wrote at the time. Suckling was not compensated to do the tastings.” Image: PR Web. wine writing -
A WINE STORY | WEDNESDAY, APRIL 11, 2012 2012 Bordeaux Tasting at Chateau Lafon-Rochet Other journalists from around the world are here to taste the 2011 vintage of wines from Saint-Julien, Pauillac, Saint-Estephe, and Haut-Medoc. Overall - aside from the Sauternes and the whites from Pessac-Leognan, this was one of the best tastings, with virtually all the wines scoring very high points. Soil: Gravels and Clay. -
A WINE STORY | WEDNESDAY, APRIL 11, 2012 Chateau Brane-Cantenac … a Viewing of Eric Boissenot’s Photographs had tasted the wind blind earlier during a formal "blind tasting" event organized by the UCG and was glad to see when the tasting was over and the scores compared, it received one of my highest ratings and read: "purple color, subtle fuchsia rim, very subtle yet focused aroma of ripe, sweet, concentrated plums with a hint of tobacco. -
A WINE STORY | WEDNESDAY, APRIL 4, 2012 En Primeur: Tasting Cru Classe & Haut Medoc wines Perhaps today at En Primeur with the tasting of Haut Medoc and Pauillac and Saint Estephe it means "luck for the vintage" for the very important Asian market. Happily the samples today were quite on point, with several within my highest score. "Do you know the significance of a golden carrot? Spice. Coffee grounds.
-
A WINE STORY | TUESDAY, APRIL 3, 2012 En Primeur: Tasting Margaux, Haut Medoc, Listrac, Moulis 2011 Vintage so here I am, a Chateau Fourcas Dupre, tasting an incredible line-up of more than forty wines. am in the 'blind tasting group' filled with names you usually see in the international wine columns. The Haut Medoc wines, Chateau Greysac and La Tour de By, both scored well. The day started off as every day should. -
A WINE STORY | TUESDAY, APRIL 3, 2012 En Primeur: Tasting Sauternes Vintage 2011 "Gorgeous weather for tasting Sauternes!". In any event, thanks Chateau Coutet for the weather (fabulous) and for also sponsoring the tasting of the region's 2011 vintage, which was excellent nearly across the board. Chateau Lafaurie-Peyraguey, a first growth Sauternes, also scored very well. -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, MARCH 14, 2012 Steampunk wine opener, man’s cave, stars, wine bars – sipped & spit TASTEVIN: “A 100-point score for a young wine is just a cry for attention.” tasting sized poursSPIT: Metrokane’s The Rabbit. Install a machine such as in the above video and you will really one-up your neighbors in the corkscrew department. SIPPED: reading. That LA Times is dropping stars for restaurant reviews? -
DR. VINO | FRIDAY, MARCH 2, 2012 Parker perfection: 100 points for 18 Bordeaux 2009s The top scores are mind-numbing. If you thought his love of Chateauneuf du Pape’s 2007 vintage was the high-water mark for his scores, think again: Parker hands out 100-point scores to 18 red wines, with several others (including first growths, Mouton, Lafite and Margaux) getting a mere 99 points. Is this serious?!?” -
DR. VINO | TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 14, 2012 Who invented wine’s 100-point scale? In “ The Emperor of Wine ,” Elin McCoy writes that Parker and his friend Victor Morgenroth tried various systems of rating and evaluating wines in their (blind) tasting group in the mid-seventies. ” Ironically, score inflation is the most likely threat to the 100-point system today. Care to guess which they were? -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | SUNDAY, JANUARY 22, 2012 Thinking About how to Rate Wine There may be people who prefer the smell and taste of Yellowtail, or who cannot distinguish between then two, and those people are welcome to their preferences and should go forth in peace and be happy. Much has been written and many debates take place about how to rate wine. But I do have some thoughts that I want to share. -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 18, 2012 ACI, NYU class, New School talk, Quintarelli Calvin Trillin has a hilarious post on ACI , a measure with false precision akin to the wine score. tasting sized poursHere’s a snippet: “Among people who think of themselves as wine connoisseurs there’s a 61 percent ACI.” What is ACI? Click through to find out… [ Slate.com ]. NYTimes.com ]. scps.NYU.edu ]. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | TUESDAY, JANUARY 3, 2012 How to Open and Enjoy an Old Bottle of Wine You can taste the discarded wine and test for TCA before pouring out the bottle as well. If I tasted an old wine that felt particularly tight, I would decant. Peter - High dexterity score is key. But ultimately the test is the taste. tasted it about every two hours until we drank it. In my case, not very often. -
A WINE STORY | SUNDAY, DECEMBER 25, 2011 Grower Champagne on Christmas Day Tasting Note: Pale straw in the glass with lovely mineral, dried fruit & citrus zest aromatics that reflect the purest expression of the Montgueux terroir. the "kind" score for a wine you want to support but don't really like. So now after two and a half days of drinking $$$$ of very fine champagne ( as a guest! Yields: 60 hl/ha. -
DR. VINO | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 20, 2011 RedNek glasses, Vinturi tested, duty free shopping — sipped and spit panel of sommeliers blind tastes wines that have been put through the Vinturi aerator. The NYT tasting panel has some good picks for all your blanc de blancs needs. tasting sized poursSIPPED: anti-snobbery. What might just be the best-selling wine glass this holiday season? Sales have hit $5 million already. CNN ]. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, DECEMBER 5, 2011 Changing critic, changing styles? In a 2006 posting on his site after attending a Spanish tasting, Martin wrote : “I have never really got under the skin of Spanish wine. This tasting does little to alleviate my apathy.” Also, a with so much ground to cover, hopefully they manage to slow down and not feel compelled to taste at nine wineries in a day. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, NOVEMBER 28, 2011 Who’s threatening us now? “Coffee experts”!! frequent use of blind tastings, known as “cuppings” * stating that coffee pros like their coffee served slightly cooler because it releases more aromatics at a lower temperature. One thing they dare bring to blind tasting is rigor. But don’t worry, wine geeks, we still have one thing they don’t: point scores! -
VIGNA UVA VINO | FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 11, 2011 Chateau Leoville Poyferre St. Julien 2003 It's allowed me to meet interesting people with broad tastes and vastly different backgrounds. Score: 98. Score: 95. Score: 93. The world of wine has been good to me. Ray O., after over a year of following my blog, recently took a trip from his hometown in Austin Texas to the Big Apple. Julien 2003. Thank you, Ray! -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 3, 2011 There’s no point! Wine retailers that say no to scores They want to crack into the US market and they figure the best way to do so is to get a score from the Wine Advocate (even if one document from the regional organization referred to the scores as “Parker points”). What do you think: should the wine industry move beyond scores? Grapes Wine Co (no Miller scores). -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 26, 2011 Pax Mahle’s enormous eggs Pax used to make full-throttle wines, syrahs and pinots mostly, that scored big Parker points. His new label, Wind Gap , offers lower-octane wines thanks in part to cool vineyard sites as well as the changing tastes of the wine maker. Just to see the eggs. Wind Gap makes about 3,000 cases of wine a year. American wine -
A WINE STORY | WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 5, 2011 Cork vs. Screwcap: Domaine LaRoche Today the Wine Media Guild had the rare and very special opportunity to taste test 'cork vs. screwcap' for the second time. Those of us lucky enough to be present in 2007 (myself included) tasted the 2002 vintage of various cru wines from Domaine LaRoche in both cork and screwcap. Michel Laroche of Domaine LaRoche. October 5, 2011. -
DR. VINO | FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 30, 2011 Why importer Jose Pastor says “no, gracias” to Wine Advocate scores And since 2009, he’s added another challenge: selling his wines without Wine Advocate scores. Citing fatigue of “living by the rule of the trade,” he told me at the recent tasting of his wines in New York that he has not journeyed to Maryland to present his portfolio to the Wine Advocate for two years. ” * * *. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 21, 2011 Learning Enough to Know That I Don't Know Anything. Imagine having to review this wine for a magazine or some sort of publication, having to score it based on one experience in 2008. How can one bottle of a wine, never mind one sip and spit at a tasting, provide sufficient information to assign the wine an absolute rating, a set of tasting notes that readers should accept as truth? -
WHY WINE BLOG | FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 2, 2011 McGregor Vineyard Rosé d'Cabernet Franc 2009 I'm letting mine sit for a few more years, but what I tasted on the visit were just extraordinaire. Score a 100 for color. The watermelon aromas and taste were like those of watermelon life savers. The dry finish was surprising, because all the aromas and taste were like sweet candies. digress, now back to my Rose'. -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, AUGUST 4, 2011 Marcassin swings at La Tache but ultimately breaks arm patting self on back Robert Parker tasted the wines with winemaker Helen Turley. At their tasting together, the Marcassin owners poured the ’06 for Parker alongside their ’06s. Meanwhile he heaped praise on the Marcassin handing out high scores and calling it “prodigious. Consider these tasting notes. 97 points. 79 points. -
DR. VINO | TUESDAY, JULY 5, 2011 When a wine fails to age, who’s to blame? In the context of a discussion about how 2001 California wines are tasting ten years on, he posted on his web site’s discussion board that synthetic cork producers would have “serious liability issues if the closure is the cause of the “failure of a ten-year old wine. Robert Parker suggests so. wine writing -
DR. VINO | TUESDAY, JUNE 28, 2011 Wells Guthrie’s Damascene conversion: “less is more” He tasted the pinot noirs and syrahs he had been making since starting his own label, Copain Wines , in 1999. The wines were made in a big, full-bodied style and had received high scores, including some 95s from Robert Parker. Brix (lower sugar level, therefore alcohol) and they tasted leaner. Search for Copain wines at retail. -
A WINE STORY | MONDAY, JUNE 13, 2011 Want to win a trip to the Languedoc? The morning started with the competitors blind tasting three wines: one white, one red, and one sweet red. After the grading, we chose the highest- scoring blind tasting reports as finalists. NY area sommeliers do! So today I was a one of four judges to find the most 'Languedoc-Roussillion" savvy sommelier. -
A WINE STORY | MONDAY, MAY 30, 2011 2010 Bordeaux: Wine Spectator James Molesworth Reviews also tasted these wines at En Primeur, and agree with his notes. Pierre Montegut made my visit to Ch Suduiraut a lot of fun -- I picked botrityzed grapes, got a lot of arm exercise pressing the grapes, and then enjoyed a vertical tasting of several vintages with gourmet Chinese food from the best Chinese restaurant in Bordeaux. -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, MAY 12, 2011 This wine rox!! #tastingnotes #grammar #scores While I could see grammar and readability in tasting notes–either user-generated or from critics–making a difference on sales, wine writing (for better or generally for worse) has its own Mechanical Turk for smoothing out all those pesky words: the score. will blow yer mind! An interesting phenomenon to be sure. -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, MAY 4, 2011 Parker on Bordeaux 2010: great but not *the greatest* Apparently the latest issue of Robert Parker’s The Wine Advocate came out yesterday with Parker’s reviews for the 2010 barrel samples and in-bottle tastings of 2008s. But Parker has given the general comment that 2010 ranks as one of “the three greatest Bordeaux vintages I have tasted in my career alongside 2009 and 2005. -
A WINE STORY | WEDNESDAY, APRIL 20, 2011 Chateau FonReaud: En Primeur Tasting You are looking at a picture of the post-tasting refreshments at Chateau Fonreaud, Cru Bourgeois Superiieur in Listrac-Medoc. At the moment of the picture, we had just finished the tasting of Listrac, Mouis, Medoc, and Margaux wines. Looks like paradise, yes? Notably fresh acidity countered by grainy medium plus tannins. -
A WINE STORY | TUESDAY, APRIL 19, 2011 En Primeur: Sauternes & Barsac As always, I tasted blind, finding it interesting to note the nuances between wines of the same vintage and relatively same region. When the tasting was over and the "answer sheets" passed around, I was pleased to see that some of my favorite wineries got the best scores. The 2010 vintage represented some fabulous sweet wines. -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, APRIL 13, 2011 Three cask monte, Bordeaux 2010, Bosnia – sipped & spit Hardy Wallace (above) dropped in on the en primeurs tastings and handed out his scores ranging from 101.00 Jancis Robinson provides a primer in the various ways that samples at the en primeurs tastings can be manipulated to show their best. Bordeaux tasting sized poursSIPPED: the zany. to 102.36 points in.17 Eater ]. -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, APRIL 7, 2011 Did social media save a winery from bankruptcy? Two bloggers organized a public tasting of his wines in Paris. He wrote in a posting on his blog that making “Parkerized wines was never his objective but during his deepest, darkest moments, he did think that if he got a 95-point score from Parker that all his problems would be solved. case study is unfolding in France. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, MARCH 28, 2011 Should critics embargo Bordeaux 2010 scores? #jancis Jancis Robinson floated a novel idea on her website last week: what if critics, who descend on Bordeaux shortly to taste 2010 barrel samples, withheld their scores until the Bordeaux trade had finished their pre-sale campaign (known as en primeur )? Bordeaux wine writing -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, MARCH 9, 2011 Skulduggery, cellar, chilling red, Bordeaux brands – sipped and spit SPIT: scores. post on the Liv-Ex blog suggests a change from scores to brands. tasting sized poursSIPPED: a new meaning for, “wine, down the hatch! [ source via reddit]. SIPPED: skulduggery. Alder Yarrow has one of his quasi transcripts up about a fascinating panel discussion on alcohol, levels and balance. vinography ]. -
A WINE STORY | TUESDAY, JANUARY 25, 2011 La Soiree des Grands Crus in NYC! Curious to taste the "next generation" of Bordeaux? This event will be held at 82 Mercer, a space that will be transformed into a modern wine cellar, where guests will taste 23 fine wines paired with cheeses, hors d'oeuvres, and chocolates by Francois Payard of FPBNY will create just for the event. -- and it gets even better! -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 19, 2011 State dinner menu with Hu Jintao: “quintessentially American” I’ve never tried the DuMOL Russian River Chard (about $50; find this wine ), but several tasting notes on CellarTracker describe it as big and oaky. CellarTracker users really like this wine ; Jay Miller, reviewer for The Wine Advocate, scored it 100 points. But what’s in the glass? Chardonnay and lobster? Check. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | TUESDAY, JANUARY 18, 2011 Sunday Lunch for the Ages - A Guided Tour of the Early Days of Rosenthal Wine Merchant There was no note taking, point scoring, chest thumping, one-upping, well-I-once-drank-a-1952 recounting, check listing but not truly drinking and understanding, nonsense. This past weekend I participated in one of the greatest wine events of my life. This was not a business lunch. The wines were very special. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, JANUARY 17, 2011 Silent movies, Lafite empties, oldest wine – sipped and spit SIPPED: wine from the pre-score era. But how did the consumers know if it was any good since it didn’t have a score out of 100? tasting sized poursSIPPED: silence. This one is for the rare Yvon Metras Felurie ’09 from magnum; other videos include an ’06 Barbaresco from Jero anda ’70 Jordan Cab from mag. -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 12, 2011 Who makes money in wine writing? About 80% of CellarTracker revenue comes from voluntary payments from users who actually generate the site’s tasting notes. And, it seems, only for those with tasting notes and point scores: readers appear willing to pay for buying guides but not for discussion and commentary. “I do it on the web for free.. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | MONDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2010 What Makes a Good Vintage? And if it got a low score, or if the vintage wasn't listed on the sheet, I would pass. think about vintage now when I buy a special bottle of wine, but I think about them according to my own taste and experience. Tags: Tastings McDuff Jeremy Parzen Italy Technical Stuff Levi Dalton One of the things I used was a vintage chart. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2010 Robert De Niro, old Champagne, allergies and China 3x — sipped & spit Robert De Niro honors Francis Ford Coppola’s cinematic achievements–by commenting on his wine (and their scores). Tags: tasting sized pours SIPPED: critiquing the critics. Be sure to check out the video for the PinotShiraCab! LA Weekly ]. SIPPED: 19th century Champagne. Must not have been yellow label, then! WSJ ]. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 2010 A Conversation with Neal Rosenthal - Part 2 BG: You'll taste these all in the next few weeks? I've made a career on tasting wines young and having a sense of whether they will age well, or be better young, but I have to check on them to follow their development. Their wine vocabulary encompasses 20 descriptors and a point score. NR: By tasting and drinking. -
DR. VINO | TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 2010 A Year of Wine – get your personalized copy here! It replaces the numerical scoring system with some strongly flavored common sense. Choosing the perfect wine for a special occasion is like selecting the perfect pitch to hit an RBI double with men in scoring position. — Bobby Abreu , starting right fielder, New York Yankees. So don’t delay for this personalized gift! -
A WINE STORY | SATURDAY, OCTOBER 23, 2010 A Visit to Segura Viudas with Vineyard Manager Sebastia Raventos Pascual The grower is paid according to how well his or her grapes scored. Quality Can Be Tasted in the Glass. Think of Cava sparkling wine, and chances are the familiar brown and gold label of Segura Viudas comes to mind. Few people realize that this popular wine is actually named after the man who founded it in the 1950s. The Penedes. -
A WINE STORY | WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 22, 2010 Sparklers: Schramsberg takes on Champagne you might think to yourself, walking into a room and sitting down in front of six rose colored wines, all to be tasted blind. And as we sniffed and swirled the wines blind, I was already imagining how horrible it would be for Hugh when the scores were collected and the Champagne “imposter was easily detected. Schram and J. -
DR. VINO | FRIDAY, AUGUST 6, 2010 Ribeira Sacra is en fuego when the weather is hot I keep meaning to do a comparative tasting of wines made from the mencia grape. It’s reminiscent of a cru Beaujolais, although a tad darker in color, but with that same lively acidity, bright fruit and scoring highly on the drinkability scale. But every time I get a bottle, I drink it! Case in point: D. Excellent! on the label). -
ALICE FEIRING | MONDAY, AUGUST 2, 2010 The Misuse of Natural They were so sweet and earnest, and why they wanted me to taste their wine, I do not know. Now you might love them, and that's fine, drink them, buy them, love them as much as their 90 + score indicates, but besides the wines which were monolithic turn offs, the marketing with earnest men, farmers provoked a gag. hated them, the wines. -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, JULY 22, 2010 Tasting note generator given 99+ pt rating! Wine writers, already about as endangered as the Iberian lynx thanks to the sagging media world (not screwcaps), have something new to fear– automatically generated tasting notes ! Have a taste of what the site spits out: Fully refined almost corpulent Chenin Blanc. Hits you with sage, boggling cardboard and bashful mint. -
A WINE STORY | TUESDAY, JULY 20, 2010 Tasting Sauvignon Blanc for Summer “I want a wine that tastes like summer,” the chic woman tells the clerk at an upscale wine store. Though its home is in Loire Valley of France, most Americans are more familiar with the fresh vibrant taste of Sauvignon Blanc from New Zealand. On the palate, citrus dominates and you can actually taste the sharp minerals and stone. -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, JULY 15, 2010 James Suckling, Le Tour, Amazon – sipped and spit SPIT: en primeur scores? Further, “The wines will be reviewed in our standard blind-tastings in the company’s New York office. Tags: tasting sized pours wine writing James Suckling is retiring from Wine Spectator after 29 years. SIPPED: new owners. Evesham Wood , a small producer in Oregon, has been sold. Avalon wine ]. -
A WINE STORY | MONDAY, MAY 10, 2010 Sud de France Top-Scoring Wines at Maison de la Region Languedoc-Roussillon Today the trade had the tchance to discover and taste over 70 wines that were awarded top scores by esteemed critics so look for them in your wine shop or favorite restaurant soon. would like to think I dazzled him by blind tasting the Domaine de la Coste rose and stating it was cinsault with a bit of grenache. Arnaud Moynier. -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, APRIL 28, 2010 Bordeaux 2009: all over but the pricing In an article entitled “Once Upon a Time (1899, 1929, 1949, 1959, 2009), he lavished praise on the vintage, particularly the cabernet blends of the left bank, and on many wines individually: 21 wines received scores of potentially 100 points. Robert Parker posted his reviews of Bordeaux 2009 yesterday on his subscription web site. -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, APRIL 22, 2010 Bobby Parkerchuk, tweeting from Monkton, NJ We scored the twitter-interview, via instant messenger: Dr. Vino: Bobby, how would you describe yourself? BP: bro, try to keep up… the most compelling vintage of any viticultural region I have ever tasted. The wine world just got wackier. The bio reads: “Wine guy, hedonist, host of Winery Advocate TV. Loves points. -
A WINE STORY | WEDNESDAY, APRIL 14, 2010 Brane-Cantenac: Speaking about 2009 Vintage with Henri Lurton just returned from Bordeaux where I had attended En Primeur, a week long tasting for international fine wine journalists to taste the new 2009 vintage. After the 2009 Margaux blind tasting, I discovered I too had given it top marks. Henri Lurton. What, if any, challenges did you have during the growing season? -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, APRIL 5, 2010 Bordeaux 2009 en primeur — the dispatches! Over the past month, critics and wine trade buyers have been on the ground in Bordeaux, tasting the 2009 vintage before they go on pre-sale (as “futures ) in the coming months. In it, she expresses how difficult it is to taste unfinished wines, calling them “raw, hard, closed, astringent and achingly tannic. Overall. -
SLAKED | TUESDAY, MARCH 9, 2010 Antica Terra, Botanica, and Lillian Tasted alongside other wines of the vintage, it clearly stands head and shoulders above the rest. Unfortunately, my palate was slightly cracked that day, so I tasted the wines only briefly. We also tasted Maggie's cult central coast syrah, Lillian. In short, Maggie's pinot noirs from Willamette Valley are not of this world. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | SUNDAY, FEBRUARY 21, 2010 How Long Should a Wine Age? Unless you often buy at auction, or have been buying and cellaring wine for a very long time, you're probably like me - you drink scores of younger wines for every truly mature bottle you drink. remember asking my friend Peter about this as we drove from one cellar tasting to another in Burgundy a little over a year ago. Fully mature? -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 18, 2010 Pinot evil: French court finds 12 guilty in Gallo faux pinot On Marketplace Morning Report this morning, a commentator said that consumers don’t even know what pinot noir tastes like. Does $9 pinot really taste like pinot noir? A French court found 12 executives guilty of selling the equivalent of 18 million bottles of cheaper wine as pinot noir. The accused made seven million euros ($9.5 -
ALICE FEIRING | TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 16, 2010 Remise Flashback Its got a reputation was as one of those wild and wooly bad boy tastings with wines that mostly were unhealthy advertisements for unsulfured wine. If that had been true, the tasting has matured. don't need tastings notes. And the winemaker gets extra cute score as well. But don't worry, it hasn't matured that much. -
ALICE FEIRING | TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 16, 2010 La Remise in More Depth Its got a reputation was as one of those wild and wooly bad boy tastings with wines that mostly were unhealthy advertisements for unsulfured wine. If that had been true, the tasting has matured. don't need tastings notes. And the winemaker gets extra cute score as well. But don't worry, it hasn't matured that much. -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, JANUARY 28, 2010 Mayacamas Vineyards – tasting notes and more, from John Gilman There is some duplication with Evan Dawson’s travel post from yesterday but there is also much new, including John’s tasting notes from Mayacamas Cabernet 2003, 1991, 1985, 1974, & 1968. Tasting this wine takes me back to the excitement I had tasting the newly released 1986 Bordeaux. 2015-2050. 2017-2050. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | FRIDAY, JANUARY 22, 2010 Deep Thoughts on Deliciousness Here is the quote: The expression of terroir demonstrates the intellectual side of cru Beaujolais, but another element that is often ignored, particularly in an environment driven by professional blind tastings and numeric scoring, is sheer drinkability: the capacity of a wine to compel us to keep returning to it over and over again. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, JANUARY 11, 2010 Does the Wine Advocate buy over $700,000 worth of wine a year? Parker publicly dismissed her assertion, saying she had “no clue as to whether I spend a dollar or a million dollars on wines to be tasted. ) In the related article , Marvin Shanken admitted that the Wine Spectator, which has many more subscribers and much higher revenues than the Wine Advocate, was dependent on free samples. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, DECEMBER 21, 2009 Vote now! Wine Person of the Decade [the Naughties] Eric LeVine : Formerly of Microsoft, LeVine opened CellarTracker.com to the public in April 2004; now, it is the dominant site for user-generated tasting notes with over one million wine reviews. Thanks to everyone for the fascinating discussion suggesting nominees for the Wine Person of the Decade. Now it’s voting time! -
DR. VINO | FRIDAY, DECEMBER 11, 2009 Advertising and ratings, binge drinking, screwcap suit – sipped and spit Wineries that advertise in Wine Spectator have their wines score better–but only by less than one point. SPIT: binge drinking; SIPPED: wine tasting. An elite girls’ school in England has a new approach to tackling the problem of binge drinking: wine tastings. SIPPED: number crunching. Revolutionary!! SPIT: closures. -
ALICE FEIRING | MONDAY, DECEMBER 7, 2009 Falling For Madeira/The Morgan Library Tasting Last year, Mr. Berk scored a number of trophies when the last remaining Leacock sold off the family jewels (methinks, heresy, but what could be done? God Bless Mannie Berk. The man didn't fancy the wine.) Before this moment I had had the odd bottle of M. No, not great quantities but enough that certainly put Port in its place. -
VIGNA UVA VINO | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 1, 2009 Cameron Hughes Lot 143 Howell Mountain Napa Valley Cabernet 2007 More tasting notes from the Snooth California Cabernet Sauvignon Blind Tasting earlier this month. would be shocked if it scored anything less than 92 points. Made from 90% Cabernet, 6% Tempranillo, 4% Syrah. This lot in particular has been nothing less than mind-blowing. -
VIGNA UVA VINO | MONDAY, NOVEMBER 30, 2009 Cameron Hughes Lot 116 Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 My tasting notes from the Snooth California Cabernet Sauvignon Blind Tasting earlier this month yielded this natural winner for me. Sourced from some of the best vineyards in Mount Veeder, Oakville, Rutherford, and Spring Mountain, this wine receives continual 91, 92, and 93 point scores. -
SLAKED | TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 24, 2009 2004 Argiano Brunello di Montalcino ** tasted the 2004 ** recently at Serrafina. It will receive a higher score if served at a proper termperature and with proper aeration and/or bottle age. Maybe it's not too terribly popular to admit, but Argiano is one of my go-to Brunello producers.Luckily, the wine isn't difficult to find. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 2009 WSJ: wine-rating system is badly flawed The story also applies the discussion to wine ratings and scores, underscoring their inherent subjectivity even though pallets of wine are bought and sold every day on these snapshots. “ A Hint of Hype, A Taste of Illusion WSJ. Think that would fly in a sales email? Yeah, me either. Anyway, check out the article. -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, OCTOBER 22, 2009 White wine, red wine, the frontal cortex, spooky store – sipped and spit “we shouldn’t expect our poor olfactory cortex to be able to reliably assign an exact point score… [ Scienceblogs ]. Tags: tasting sized pours wine and health SIPT: white wine. White wine has not ridden the good-for-you train as far, fast or as well as red wine. Yesterday, white wine almost suffered derailment. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, OCTOBER 19, 2009 What’s in a score? [audio] I recently posted about blind tasting Bordeaux 2005 with Robert Parker. Last week, via the “inaugural edition of his monthly e-newsletter, he produced his own summation of the public tasting, which included new, “official scores for all the wines tasted. At the event, he had not scored any of the wines. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | SATURDAY, OCTOBER 17, 2009 Blind Tasting and Scoring 2004 White Burgundy A friend recently hosted his tasting group and invited me as a stand-in. They were blind tasting 2004 white Burgundies, a great theme in and of itself. But the group added a fascinating wrinkle to this tasting. Would the "best" wines get the best scores? We agreed not to discuss during the tasting, and we got to work. -
DR. VINO | TUESDAY, OCTOBER 6, 2009 Natural wines, premox, chenin blanc, 07 Port and Rhone – John Gilman Tasting through her recent vintages here- particularly in a vineyard such the premier cru of Clavoillon (which used to be a bid of an underperformer in the Leflaive stable)- it is pretty hard not to agree with her wholeheartedly in the greater signature of terroir in the Leflaive wines today. Natural wines are growing in popularity. -
DR. VINO | FRIDAY, OCTOBER 2, 2009 Blind tasting is tough – tasting Bordeaux 2005 with Robert Parker On Wednesday evening I attended a tasting of fifteen wines from Bordeaux 2005. Aside from that outrageous apparent quality of the wines, the tasting had two other attractions: the ability to taste some of the top wines blind and to do so in the company of Robert Parker. He said he hadn’t tasted these wines since 2007. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 14, 2009 Study: points influence consumer perceptions! They gave 163 volunteers a taste of 2006 Clos de los Siete, a $15ish wine from Michel Rolland’s Argentina property and rated 92 points from the Wine Advocate. They told some of the participants the score beforehand, others not, and a told a third set that the wine got 72 points. Tags: wine scores Siegrist et al. -
ALICE FEIRING | SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 13, 2009 Champagne! For this Wall Street Journal Magazine champagne story ( I spend, let's see, two months closing), I tasted some champagnes around the kitchen table--with the intend of finding champers that were worth their price tag. Cato Corners, an especially a firm and complex buffalo tallegio scored at DiPalo. Tasters we had. long time ago. -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2009 Sierra missed, parte dos! A blind tasting of Sierra Carche Here’s a reminder from our earlier coverage: “What happens when a reviewer tastes a good bottle, but some consumers buy what appears to be a completely different product? joined Kenney and a dozen other tasters for a blind tasting organized by Daniel Posner, a partner in the wine store, Grapes The Wine Co. -
DR. VINO | TUESDAY, JULY 28, 2009 Lots on labels – but not on American wines For those who haven’t checked out the saga (see Felix Salmon’s excellent summary over on Reuters.com ), an influential critic gave a wine brand called Sierra Carche the score of 96, retailers sold the wine touting that score, but many consumers then found the wine undrinkable (as the critic also did 10 months later). -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, JULY 22, 2009 Sierra missed – the saga of Sierra Carche 2005 What happens when a reviewer tastes a good bottle, but some consumers buy what appears to be a completely different product? Kenney wrote last week that “During a ten month period I had exchanged seven emails with DrBigJ, reminding/imploring him to taste the sent bottle…to no avail.. Think it couldn’t happen? Big mistake. -
WINE TASTING GUY | THURSDAY, JULY 2, 2009 “Kosher brand tops the chart” Just like a wine tasting, the panel tasted 5 marshmallows BLIND (cool huh?) and scored each, [.]. Not JUST kosher, but kosher FROM ISRAEL! OK, so it was not a kosher wine, rather kosher marshmallows. I found the article “Kosher brand tops the chart in the San Fransisco Chronicle while I was out West the other week. -
DR. VINO | WEDNESDAY, JUNE 24, 2009 Spot the 62 pointer - Viu 1 from Chile - and some Spanish What does a 62 point wine taste like? Not that I follow scores for wine very much, but a 62 pointer? Or, conversely, if you disagree with the critic giving the score, perhaps it was fantastic? We settled into a booth and after a warm up tasting of some Spanish wines (described below) and moved into the Viu 1 vertical. -
DR. VINO | FRIDAY, JUNE 12, 2009 A historic tasting Down Under - Bin 60A, Grange, Hill of Grace He dribbles to the other end of the court, pulls up for a jumper right before the three point line, shoots, and scores! But a tasting last week in the Barossa Valley did showcase some of Australia’s most amazing wines of all time. It’s the wine tasting equivalent of a buzzer beater and a walk off grand slam all in one. -
DR. VINO | SUNDAY, MAY 31, 2009 The state of Australian wine - and Landmark Australia We will spend the next five days in the Barossa Valley tasting through three sessions a day with leading wine makers from throughout Australia including Jeffrey Grosset and Brian Croser among many others. Over the past couple of decades, Australian wine has seen two tremendous, parallel booms, one at the low end and one at the high end. -
DR. VINO | TUESDAY, APRIL 7, 2009 G20, Bordeaux pricing, Cake wine, Australia - sipped and spit She asserts this is largely because of the success of “ubiquitous and vapid low end wines and the high alcohol wines that receive big scores from the Wine Advocate. That’s why I’ll be joining a group wine writers and sommeliers there in June for the Landmark Australia tasting. SIPPED: English wine. Decanter ]. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | SUNDAY, APRIL 5, 2009 Peter Liem's ChampagneGuide.Net On the palate this site is a harmonious balance of background information and context, complex producer profiles, and vivid tasting notes. Sorry - my little tasting note-as-review joke went on longer than I thought it would, but I was enjoying myself and that's the most important thing, isn't it? Peter Liem is my good friend. -
SLAKED | THURSDAY, MARCH 26, 2009 2004 Hanzell Chardonnay The 2004 is now five years old and tastes like a young Kongsgaard The Judge. One 99 point score from Robert Parker is pretty much all it would take. couple more scores like that, combined with their history and pedigree, and good luck finding a bottle for under $200. Pale hay color, but big Wow! -
SLAKED | MONDAY, MARCH 16, 2009 What's In a 95 Point Wine? I'm not sure what it means to apply a numerical score to the taste of a wine. scoring 95 point wines, it's the fact that they taste almost purely, and almost identically, like blueberry, and not much else. In a word: blueberry. Even my four-star deliciousness scale leaves something to be desired. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, MARCH 9, 2009 Bordeaux futures, wine investment, waste, insurance - sipped and spit But he admitted that they probably will after they hear nice things about their wines at the en primeurs tastings in early April. Score one for the winemakers! Tags: Bordeaux tasting sized pours wine collecting SPIT: Bordeaux futures. SIPPED: Bordeaux past. Bloomberg ]. SIPPED: industrial waste over Givry. SPIT: excise tax. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | MONDAY, MARCH 2, 2009 Thoughts on Points He uses a range for wines tasted in barrel - a wine might be scored 88-91, for example. According to his scoring explanation, that means that the wine will be somewhere between high quality to outstanding. Wines tasted when market-ready are assigned single scores. And why not hate? understand all of those ideas. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, FEBRUARY 23, 2009 Review roundup - A Year of Wine As more wine sales shift online in coming years, particularly through the prospect of Amazon entering wine retail, wineries will have to adjust to this form of popular criticism, which could certainly serve as a sharp break with the dominant sales model of the past couple decades, selling wines based on the scores of critics. Thanks, Joe! -
SLAKED | WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 4, 2009 Girard Winery Winemaking and operations continue out of the Carneros plant, while the tasting room is located at 6795 Washington Street in Yountville. Even the 2005 Pritchard Hill (which I only tasted briefly at a trade tasting) and which received high scores from Wine Spectator, shows more restraint than many of its peers. Elegance. -
SLAKED | MONDAY, FEBRUARY 2, 2009 2006 Ridge Vineyards Dusi Ranch ATP * Ridge Vineyards' first Advanced Tasting Program release of 2009 , from 48 barrels of 100% zinfandel planted in 1923 on the Dusi Ranch one mile east of Highway 101 in Paso Robles, this big, mouth coating zinfandel is loaded with ripe red fruit. The wine is concentrated, ruby red, and has mild smoke and bacon notes underneath. -
DR. VINO | THURSDAY, JANUARY 22, 2009 Three questions with Christine Saahs of Nikolaihof, Wachau The Im Weingebirge Smaragd bottling is always one of my favorite gruner veltliners and indeed the 2006 I tasted had great, rich intensity and a long minerally finish. was happy to have the chance to chat about three things during a busy trade tasting on Tuesday. Nikolaihof also makes several very good Rieslings. Hers are 12.5%]. -
BROOKLYN GUY LOVES WINE | WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 14, 2009 Domaine des Croix, Beaune The first vintage at the Domaine was 2005 and the wines were well received by Allen Meadows at Burghound, most of them scoring in the high 80's to low 90's. We arrived at their house and David first took us to the cellar to taste his wines. I've never tasted wine that young before. There is one white wine, a Corton-Charlemagne. -
DR. VINO | MONDAY, JANUARY 5, 2009 Screwcaps, scores, riesling, the Loire, Cali cab: John Gilman part two So buckle up and get ready to hear his thoughts on what’s wrong with Riesling from Austria and Australia, screwcaps and their problems, the Loire, California cab then and now, indigenous yeasts, roto-fermenters, small oak barrels, wines over 14% alcohol and why he uses scores! Wine scores. German Riesling. just don’t get it. -
SLAKED | MONDAY, DECEMBER 1, 2008 1995 Ridge Vineyards Monte Bello have tasted this twice before, and my thoughts on the wine have been consistent. Parker scored it 94-96 points, and compared it to "the great 1992 and 1991." At thirteen, the 1995 Monte Bello is still a child. keep waiting for this wine to fully reveal itself. It won't. Only then will its ripe red fruits emerge. As Robert Parker Jr. | |